Return to MLB Previews

2025-09-10 Tigers at Yankees Matchup Preview

Education Hero Image

The Detroit Tigers and New York Yankees face off in a mid-September contest with potential playoff implications as the season draws to a close.

Card Image
This article is powered by MyBookie

Up to $1,000 Welcome Bonus

Start Now
Education Hero Image

Starting Pitcher Matchup

Right-hander Jack Flaherty will take the mound for the Detroit Tigers, while the New York Yankees will counter with left-hander Carlos Rodon. This pitching matchup sets the stage for a compelling contest, pitting Flaherty's diverse arsenal against the Yankees' potent lineup, and Rodon's power against the Tigers' determined hitters.

Detroit Tigers' Offensive Outlook

The Detroit Tigers enter this game showcasing an offense that has demonstrated steady performance throughout the 2025 season. Their team Expected Weighted On-Base Average of .331 indicates a solid ability to get on base and drive in runs. With a combined Wins Above Replacement of 20.3, the Tigers have shown they can produce quality at-bats that contribute to overall team success. Flaherty's effectiveness will be crucial to how well the Tigers' offense can perform, with a dependence on his ability to keep Yankee hitters at bay.

A critical factor for the Tigers' success will be how well their hitters perform against Carlos Rodon's pitching repertoire. They need to capitalize on opportunities when Rodon makes mistakes and ensure they don't allow him to settle into a rhythm. The Tigers' focus should be on hitting the ball hard and making smart decisions on the basepaths. Their strategy against Rodon might involve working deep into counts to tire him out or forcing him to throw pitches he's less comfortable with. This approach will test Rodon's stamina and control, potentially leading to more favorable hitting situations for the Tigers.

New York Yankees' Offensive Prowess

The New York Yankees boast a formidable offense, characterized by a high Expected Weighted On-Base Average of .348. This statistic underlines their ability to consistently generate scoring opportunities. Their collective Wins Above Replacement stands at an impressive 28.9, indicative of the significant impact their hitters have on the team's overall performance. The Yankees will aim to exploit any weaknesses in Flaherty's pitching, looking to capitalize on his pitch selection and command.

The key for the Yankees will be to leverage their power hitters and ensure they are disciplined at the plate. By making Flaherty work hard and avoiding easy outs, the Yankees can increase their chances of scoring runs. The Yankees' hitters must be ready to adjust their approach based on Flaherty's pitch mix and exploit any patterns they observe. Their familiarity with the home field advantage and the confidence it brings could also play a role in their offensive output. Ultimately, the Yankees will aim to control the game's tempo and put constant pressure on Flaherty, forcing him to make mistakes.

Pitching Matchup Analysis

Jack Flaherty's ability to command the strike zone and vary his pitch selection will be paramount in neutralizing the Yankees' offense. His challenge will be to keep the ball low in the zone, induce ground balls, and avoid giving up home runs. The Yankees' hitters are known for their power, so Flaherty's strategy will likely involve a mix of fastballs, breaking balls, and changeups to keep them off balance.

Conversely, Carlos Rodon will need to rely on his velocity and movement to stifle the Tigers' offense. He will aim to establish early dominance with his fastball and then mix in his secondary pitches to keep the hitters guessing. Rodon's ability to maintain his composure under pressure and make critical pitches in key situations will be crucial. The Tigers' hitters will be looking to capitalize on any mistakes, so Rodon must stay sharp and execute his pitches with precision.

Game Prediction

Given the offensive capabilities of both teams and the strengths of the starting pitchers, this game promises to be a tightly contested affair. The Yankees' slightly higher Expected Weighted On-Base Average and Wins Above Replacement give them a slight edge, but Flaherty's experience and ability to mix his pitches could keep the Tigers in the game. The outcome may hinge on which team can capitalize on situational hitting and which pitcher can maintain control in crucial moments.

Tigers 5 Yankees 4