Return to MLB Previews

2025-09-16 Guardians at Tigers Matchup Preview

Education Hero Image

The Detroit Tigers aim to leverage their potent offense against the Cleveland Guardians' pitching in this anticipated September matchup.

Card Image
This article is powered by MyBookie

Up to $1,000 Welcome Bonus

Start Now
Education Hero Image

Starting Pitching Matchup

The Cleveland Guardians will send left-hander Joey Cantillo to the mound, while the Detroit Tigers will counter with right-hander Casey Mize. Cantillo's arsenal will be put to the test against a Tigers lineup that has demonstrated a knack for generating productive at-bats this season, while Mize will seek to exploit any weaknesses in the Guardians' approach at the plate.

Guardians' Offensive Outlook

The Cleveland Guardians' offense has been relatively lackluster, posting an expected Weighted On-Base Average of .299 this season. This indicates that their hitters, as a whole, haven't been as effective at reaching base and driving in runs as the Detroit Tigers, which is a critical factor when facing a pitcher like Casey Mize who can limit baserunners. The Guardians will need to focus on improving their contact rate and capitalizing on any mistakes Mize makes to generate scoring opportunities. Mize will likely attack with a combination of fastballs and breaking pitches, so the Guardians' hitters will need to demonstrate the ability to adjust to different speeds and movement. As a team, they will also need to improve on their walk percentage to keep the line moving.

Tigers' Offensive Prowess

The Detroit Tigers' offense presents a significant challenge to Joey Cantillo and the Guardians' pitching staff, highlighted by their .332 expected Weighted On-Base Average. This statistic showcases the Tigers' ability to consistently put runners on base and generate scoring opportunities. The Tigers' hitters possess a strong understanding of the strike zone and are adept at drawing walks, as evidenced by their walk percentage, which allows them to extend innings and put pressure on opposing pitchers. Cantillo's ability to command his pitches and minimize walks will be crucial in mitigating the Tigers' offensive threat. Detroit's ability to hit for extra bases, as demonstrated by their extra-base hit percentage, further compounds the challenge for Cantillo, who must avoid leaving pitches over the heart of the plate.

Pitching Analysis

Joey Cantillo will need to rely on his ability to locate his pitches effectively and vary his velocity to keep the Tigers' hitters off balance. His success will hinge on his ability to induce weak contact and avoid giving up home runs, particularly against a Tigers lineup that has demonstrated power potential. Cantillo must maintain a high first-strike percentage to gain an advantage in the count and prevent hitters from sitting on specific pitches. Casey Mize will aim to leverage his fastball command and slider to keep the Guardians' hitters from getting comfortable in the box. His goal will be to pitch deep into the game, limiting the opportunities for the Guardians' offense to mount rallies against the Tigers' bullpen. Mize's ability to change speeds and disrupt the timing of hitters will be essential in stifling the Guardians' offensive attack.

Defensive Considerations

Both teams' defenses will play a critical role in the outcome of the game. The Guardians' defense will need to be sharp to support Cantillo and prevent the Tigers from extending innings with errors. The Tigers' defense, anchored by strong infield play and reliable outfield coverage, will seek to limit the Guardians' opportunities to manufacture runs. A clean game defensively will be crucial for both teams.

Bullpen Outlook

The performance of both teams' bullpens could be a deciding factor, especially if the game remains close late. The Guardians' bullpen will need to be ready to step in and shut down the Tigers' offense if Cantillo struggles or is forced to exit the game early. Similarly, the Tigers' bullpen will need to be prepared to protect a lead or keep the game within reach if Mize falters. Each team's bullpen's ability to throw strikes and limit walks will be paramount in high-pressure situations. The effectiveness of each team's relief pitchers in preventing stolen bases will also be a factor to monitor, as stolen bases can shift momentum and create scoring opportunities.

Intangibles

In a mid-September matchup, both teams are likely focused on executing their game plans and securing a victory. The Tigers, playing at home, may have a slight advantage in terms of crowd support and familiarity with their surroundings. Ultimately, the team that executes better on both sides of the ball will emerge victorious. Away: Guardians 3 Home: Tigers 5