Return to MLB Previews

2025-10-05 Yankees at Blue Jays Matchup Preview

Education Hero Image

A pivotal late-season matchup sees the New York Yankees travel to face the Toronto Blue Jays with playoff implications on the line.

Card Image
This article is powered by Jazz Sports

125% Crypto Welcome Bonus

Start Now
Education Hero Image

Pitching Matchup

The New York Yankees will send left-hander Max Fried to the mound. Fried's effectiveness hinges on his ability to command his sinker, a pitch with significant horizontal movement designed to induce ground balls, and his curveball, which exhibits substantial downward break, causing hitters to swing over the top. He complements these pitches with a four-seam fastball, thrown with above-average velocity, and a changeup used to disrupt timing. His success stems from maintaining consistent arm speed and disguising his pitch selection, which keeps hitters off balance. The Toronto Blue Jays will counter with rookie right-hander Trey Yesavage. Yesavage relies heavily on his high-velocity four-seam fastball, which he pairs with a slider exhibiting late, sharp horizontal movement. He also features a curveball with a 12-6 shape and a changeup with considerable arm-side fade to neutralize left-handed hitters. His command within the strike zone and ability to locate his fastball are key to his success.

Yankees Hitting Analysis

The New York Yankees offense has performed well this season, showcasing a disciplined approach at the plate. As a team, they've accumulated a weighted on-base average of .349, indicating their ability to get on base consistently. Their collective weighted runs above average is 124.4, reflecting strong run production. Against right-handed pitching, the Yankees hitters will need to focus on identifying Yesavage's fastball early in the count and adjusting to his slider's late movement. The team's overall ability to control the strike zone will be vital in extending innings and capitalizing on any mistakes. Key for the Yankees will be ensuring that the plate discipline is at its highest, ensuring a large percentage of pitches thrown are in their favor to hit and that the percentage of pitches that they chase are extremely low.

Blue Jays Hitting Analysis

The Toronto Blue Jays offense presents a balanced attack, with a good blend of power and on-base ability. They've recorded a weighted on-base average of .339, showing a solid ability to reach base. Their weighted runs above average is 115.2, indicative of above-average offensive production. Against left-handed pitching, the Blue Jays hitters will need to be patient and avoid getting caught up in Fried's deceptive delivery. They should aim to drive pitches up in the zone and avoid chasing pitches low in the zone, especially his sinker and curveball. A key will be seeing as many pitches as possible and wearing down Fried's ability to work effectively later into the game. The Blue Jays' success will depend on their ability to work the count, draw walks, and capitalize on scoring opportunities. Like the Yankees, the team must show tremendous plate discipline if they want to have success.

Bullpen Outlook

Both the Yankees and Blue Jays possess reliable bullpens capable of shortening the game and protecting leads. The Yankees bullpen has shown stability throughout the season, with multiple arms capable of pitching in high-leverage situations. Their ability to induce ground balls and limit extra-base hits has been crucial in maintaining leads. The Blue Jays bullpen also features a mix of power arms and experienced veterans, providing manager with flexibility in late-game situations. Their ability to control the running game and limit stolen bases will be critical in close contests. Both teams will be looking to their bullpens to secure the victory in what is expected to be a tightly contested affair.

Intangibles

Given the playoff implications, both teams will undoubtedly bring a heightened sense of urgency to the game. The Yankees, with their veteran leadership and postseason experience, will look to set the tone early and establish control. The Blue Jays, playing at home, will rely on the energy of their fans to provide a boost and create a hostile environment for the opposition. The team that executes better in situational baseball, such as moving runners over and driving in runs with two outs, will likely emerge victorious. Fielding and defense will also be crucial, as any costly errors could prove decisive in a close game. This is expected to be a hard-fought battle with both teams leaving it all on the field.

Prediction

The game is expected to be a close, low-scoring affair, with both starting pitchers keeping the opposing offenses in check. The Yankees' slight edge in overall offensive production and pitching depth may give them a slight advantage. Yankees 4 Blue Jays 3